Breakthrough Blog
 
Friday Factoids: Fatalities from Energy Production Accidents

Share

Update: A commenter brought it to our attention that there have, in fact, been at least 11 fatalities from wind power accidents in the U.S. Thanks to Karen Street, at The Energy Collective, for the hat tip. According to the Caithness Windfarms Information Forum, as of March 2010 there have been 47 fatalities directly as a result of wind power worldwide.

Here are some Friday Factoids to stew on over the weekend. As usual, we'll let the numbers speak for themselves.

US fatalities from:

  • Fatalities from Deepwater Horizon offshore rig explosion: 11
  • Total fatalities in gulf oil and gas drilling since 2001: 69 (according to MMS, cited here)
  • Fatalities from Texas City BP oil refinery explosion in 2005: 15
  • Fatalities from explosion of natural gas power plant under construction in Middletown, Connecticut in February 2010: 5
  • Total fatalities from Big Branch coal mine explosion: 29
  • Annual average coal mining fatalities between 2001-2005: 30
  • Total fatalities from wind power accidents in US history: 1 (in Sherman County, Oregon in 2007)
  • Total fatalities from nuclear power plant operation or accidents in U.S. history: 0

   Like what you see? Subscribe to our RSS feed here...


Share


TrackBacks (0) 2 COMMENTS:

3 technicians died at an experimental reactor in 1961 in Idaho.
http://www.atomicarchive.com/Reports/Japan/Accidents.shtml

You're also ignoring deaths from Uranium mining:

http://www.deseretnews.com/article/1,5143,250010691,00.html

Don't get me wrong, I'd prefer nuclear power over coal plants (and the ignored radioactivity from coal ash), it's just that nuclear power has a fair number of externalized costs (though, coal is worse).

Taka, thank you for your comment.



There are certainly dangers associated with uranium mining, as with any other form of mining, and those dangers are further exacerbated by risks associated with radiation exposure (although coal and other hard rock miners are often exposed to radiation as well, and the burning of coal releases relatively large amounts of uranium and other radioactive materials into the atmosphere as well).



We did not include a factoid for recent fatalities from uranium mining, and much of the earlier mining impacts, such as those in the article you cited, were fueled by demand from the military nuclear weapons apparatus, not later civilian nuclear power operations. Like the early history of coal mining (which we don't include here), the early history of uranium mining is clearly much worse than today's operations, although both coal and uranium mining still have their impacts.



It's also worth noting in this context though, that pound-for-pound, uranium is a couple orders of magnitude more "energy dense" than coal, meaning much much less uranium must be mined, processed, 'burnt' and then reprocessed or stored to produce a given amount of energy, compared to coal. In other words, whereas coal ore, fuel and waste are measured in quantities of hundreds, thousands or even billions of tons, 'equivalent' quantities or uranium are probably described in terms of hundreds of pounds or dozens of tons. Much of the environmental and human impacts of mining and waste thus scale proportionately.



In the end though, as you clearly understand, all forms of energy have their risks and impacts (which was much the point of this post), and the key is to examine their relative risks and impacts to make informed decisions about our energy supply options. Thanks for stopping by Taka. Cheers...

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use basic HTML tags for style)
Use the <br> tag for line breaks (returns).

HTML is allowed, but in an effort to prevent SPAM if your entry contains URL's it will be held briefly for moderation.

Please email comments@thebreakthrough.org if you're experiencing problems when trying to comment.

Breakthrough Blog
RSS Subscribe to RSS Feed

twitter Follow the BTI on Twitter

twitter Join the BTI on Facebook

donate to Breakthrough

Recent Breakthrough Blog Posts

Jenkins to the Senate: How the Government Can Drive Clean Energy Innovation

While Japan turns away from nuclear power, South Korea sticks to its path

Where the Shale Gas Revolution Came From

Interview with Alex Crawley, Former Program Director for the Energy Research and Development Administration

National Journal Highlights "Beyond Boom and Bust" in Weekly Forum

Archives
Categories
Contributors

Blog advertisement
Nau Clothing
 
 
Privacy : Contact