The Breakthrough Institute

Events · Past event

Ecomodernism 2023: Slouching Towards Industrial Policy

to · Salamander Resort, Middleburg, VA

The theme of this year’s event is “Slouching Toward Industrial Policy,” which begs the question of what anyone actually means when they tout (or demean) industrial policy. Central planning or innovation policy? Market-based or state-led? Join us as we explore these questions and more.


Progressive climate advocates entered the first two years of the Biden Administration with glints of advance market commitments and technology hubs in their eyes and ended them proclaiming that a bold new era of green industrial policy had commenced. But beyond an undeniable quantitative increase in the scale of federal clean technology spending emanating from the Inflation Reduction Act and other recent post-Covid legislative initiatives, it is not entirely clear what qualitatively differentiates the current green technology regime from past federal programs and policies.

Tax credits and public-private partnerships remain the coin of the realm. IRA largely uses exactly the same policy levers that ARRA used a decade earlier. The CHIPS Act, like Sematech before it, proposes to leverage tariffs and investments in R&D, STEM education, technology hubs, and manufacturing tax credits to assure US supremacy in chip manufacturing.

One difference is the Biden Administration’s intention to leverage a “whole-of-government” approach to implementing IRA, pairing federal investment with executive action and ambitious utilization of established federal regulatory powers under the Clean Air Act to drive rapid decarbonization of the US economy. But the Administration and its allies also appear determined to drive the energy transition forward with one foot on the gas pedal and one foot on the brake, pumping hundreds of billions into clean technology and infrastructure and regulating fossil fuel emissions while also maintaining baroque regulatory apparatus through NEPA, the Jones Act, the Endangered Species Act, and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission that substantially constrain the pace and scale at which the new energy economy can be built.

All of which begs the question of what anyone actually means when they tout (or demean) industrial policy. Central planning or innovation policy? Market-based or state-led? The United States has a long history of building infrastructure - canals, dams, railways, and highways - in the national interest. And its entrepreneurs and industries, often supported by public investments in education, research, and commercialization, have been an engine of innovation for over two centuries.

But the current administration proposes to go further than this, pairing similar investment in clean technology and infrastructure with far reaching regulations predicated upon the rapid deployment of clean technology across the US economy, functionally transforming public innovation investments into government mandated production targets. The United States has little history with industrial policy of this sort and the track record of similar efforts elsewhere has been, to put it generously, mixed.

Appropriating hundreds of billions of dollars through a one-off party-line budget reconciliation vote turns out to have been the easy part. Sustaining a coherent national clean technology program over multiple decades, in the face of conservative eco-skepticism and environmental proceduralism and techno-skepticism, will likely prove far harder.

How, then, should advocates approach IRA implementation? What are the political, economic, and technological risks associated with maximalist industrial policy? What might be gleaned from the successes and failures of industrial policies past? And how might green industrial policies survive the inevitable shifts in political fortune at the federal level that any program to deeply decarbonize the US economy will need to weather?

Where Salamander Resort
500 N Pendleton St, Middleburg VA 20117