Ecomodernism 2021: Quiet Climate Policy
to · Middleburg, VA
Here as elsewhere, we have referred to climate policy as “quiet” if it swims with the tide of existing sociopolitical institutions and economic growth, if it uses technology and infrastructure as its main lever, and if it disrupts, rather than exploits, political partisanship. Such are the qualities, after all, of the types of government policy that have driven investment and deployment of lower-carbon technologies for decades—in short, the types of policies arguably responsible for most decarbonization to date. At this event, we will consider whether quiet climate policy is enough.
October 3-5 | Salamander Resort & Virtually | Middleburg, VA & Global
Quiet Climate Policy
As the nation and the world emerge, haltingly and unevenly, from the COVID-19 pandemic, advocates for climate action will need to grapple with a set of contradictions. On the one hand, the pandemic showed what type of society-wide response is possible when faced with an emergency-level threat. On the other hand, that response revealed just how thin our willingness to sacrifice is, how little trust our major governing institutions still command, and how our cultural cleavages will politicize even the most universally distributed challenges.
The early days of COVID gave some hope that some combination of mass behavioral change, sweeping public investments, and breakthrough technologies would one day soon be pressed against the climate challenge like they appeared to be applied against COVID. Yet the public’s patience with lockdowns, social distancing, and masking proved short-lived. The federal government spent unprecedented amounts on COVID relief in 2020, but in 2021 Congress seems hesitant to keep the spigot open. And perhaps of the most impressive technological marvels in recent memory, the COVID vaccines, have proven just as capable of igniting the culture war as any of our other policy and behavioral disputes.
In the end, the comparisons between COVID and climate policy may reveal more by where they diverge than where they overlap. Our post-lockdown climate politics may resemble less of the New Deal or Great Society or even the pandemic response than they resemble something much quieter.
Here as elsewhere, we have referred to climate policy as “quiet” if it swims with the tide of existing sociopolitical institutions and economic growth, if it uses technology and infrastructure as its main lever, and if it disrupts, rather than exploits, political partisanship. Such are the qualities, after all, of the types of government policy that have driven investment and deployment of lower-carbon technologies for decades—in short, the types of policies arguably responsible for most decarbonization to date.
At Ecomodernism 2021, taking place between a new Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report and the next United Nations Climate Change Conference, we will consider whether quiet policy is enough. And if it is not, what will supplement it or, even, take its place? Is it credible to imagine political support for such an alternative? What other avenues towards climate action are available to us, on either the political Left or political Right, or via foreign policy? And even if COVID failed to reorient our politics as much as many would have preferred, are there political or policy lessons yet to glean from our response to the pandemic?
